Heading - Add an empty motion.

PINAL COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
MINUTES
Wednesday, January 8, 2025
9:32 AM

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS


Chairman Mike Goodman

Supervisor, District 2


Vice-Chairman Jeffrey McClure 

 Supervisor, District 4


Rich Vitiello
Supervisor, District 1


Stephen Q. Miller
Supervisor, District 3


Jeff Serdy
Supervisor, District 5


PINAL COUNTY ADMINISTRATIVE COMPLEX

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS HEARING ROOM

135 N. PINAL STREET
FLORENCE, AZ 85132

 
Members/Staff Present

All Presentations are attached to the Agenda at:

Click Here to View the Regular Session Agenda

 

and a Video Recording of this meeting can be viewed at:

Click Here to View Video Recording

 

Chairman Goodman offered for the Invocation by Pastor Ben Lee, Living Waters Bible Church, San Tan Valley and the pledge of allegiance by Supervisor Vitiello.

 

The Pinal County Board of Supervisors convened at 9:32 a.m. this date. The meeting was called to order by Chairman Goodman.

 

Members Present: Chairman Mike Goodman; Vice-Chairman Jeffrey McClure; Supervisor Rich Vitiello; Supervisor Stephen Q. Miller; Supervisor Jeff Serdy

 

Staff Present: County Manager, Leo Lew; County Attorney, Brad Miller; Chief Civil Deputy County Attorney, Chris Keller; Clerk of the Board, Natasha Kennedy and Deputy Clerk of the Board, Kelsey Pickard

(1)County Manager's Report (Information Only). (Leo Lew)
Item Action: Information Only
(2)Supervisor District update(s) regarding notable current or upcoming events concerning the district (Information Only). (Mike Goodman)
Item Action: Information Only
(3)Discussion/approval/disapproval of the Proclamation to designate the week of January 19, 2025, through January 25, 2025, as "Medicolegal Death Investigator" Professionals Week in honor of the public service provided by the Pinal County Medical Examiner's Office. (Andre Davis/John Hu)
Item Action: Approved
(4)Purchasing Division Report - January 8, 2025. (Angeline Woods)
Item Action: Approved
(5)CONSENT ITEMS:
All items indicated by an asterisk (*) will be handled by a single vote as part of the consent agenda, unless a Board Member, County Manager, or member of the public objects at the time the agenda item is called.
*A.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of Minutes from November 20, 2024 Regular Meeting of the Board of Supervisors. (Natasha Kennedy)

Item Action: Approved

*B.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of the recommendation to the Arizona Department of Liquor License and Control for the Special Event License Application of Ruth Canamar, for the 24 Hours in the Old Pueblo Event to be held at the Arizona State Land Department, located at Tipperary Road West of Willow Springs Road/E. Willow Springs Drive, Oracle, Arizona on the following dates:

  • Friday, February 14, 2025, from 11:00 a.m. to 11:30 p.m.
  • Saturday, February 15, 2025, from 10:00 a.m. to 11:30 p.m.
  • Sunday, February 16, 2025, from 10:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.  

Additionally, authorizing the Clerk of the Board to execute and submit all necessary documents to the State. Supervisor District #4. (Natasha Kennedy)

Item Action: Approved

*C.Discussion/approval/disapproval of the recommendation to the Arizona Department of Liquor License and Control for the Special Event License Application of Ileen Snoddy, for the Sampling at the Superstitions Event to be held at the Superstition Mountain Museum, located at 4087 E. Apache Trail, Apache Junction, Arizona on Saturday, February 1, 2025, from 4:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. Additionally, authorizing the Clerk of the Board to execute and submit all necessary documents to the State. Supervisor District #5. (Natasha Kennedy)

Item Action: Approved

*D.Discussion/approval/disapproval of the recommendation to the Arizona Department of Liquor License and Control for the Special Event License Application of Ileen Snoddy, for the Magic of Mexican Artistry Fundraiser Event to be held at the Superstition Mountain Museum, located at 4087 E. Apache Trail, Apache Junction, Arizona on Saturday, March 8, 2025, from 4:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. Additionally, authorizing the Clerk of the Board to execute and submit all necessary documents to the State. Supervisor District #5. (Natasha Kennedy)

Item Action: Approved

*E.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of Supervisor Miller's reappointment of Richard G. Kennedy, Casa Grande, AZ 85122 to the Adjustments & Appeals Board, term of service will be from January 4, 2025, through January 3, 2029. Supervisor District #3. (Natasha Kennedy)

Item Action: Approved

*F.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of Additional FY 24/25 Non-Profit Contributions. (Leo Lew) 

Item Action: Approved

*G.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Award Agreement IPG 24S-706 under the Invasive Plant Grant between the Arizona Department of Forestry and Fire Management and Pinal County, through the Pinal County Board of Supervisors, beginning upon execution, ending December 31, 2027, for $192,000. A matching contribution of $30,000 is required and has been budgeted in the FY 24/25 budget. This grant will be used by the Open Space, Trails, and Regional Parks Department to remove invasive and noxious weeds at Peralta Regional Park. Acceptance requires an amendment to the FY 24/25 budget to transfer reserve appropriation from Fund 213 (Grants/Project Contingency) to Fund 10 (Parks General Fund) to increase revenue and expenditure appropriations. Supervisor District #5. (Kelley Fox/Himanshu Patel)

Item Action: Approved

*H.Discussion/approval/disapproval authorizing an amended application submission to the Arizona State Parks and Trails for a Land and Water Conservation Fund Grant (LWCF) for an additional $500,000 bringing the award total to $1,500,000. The additional funding will be used by the Open Space, Trails, and Regional Parks Department for the Palo Verde Regional Park development. Supervisor Districts #1 and #5. (Kent Taylor/Himanshu Patel)

Item Action: Approved as presented to update the agenda to reflect that this is an amendment under Resolution No. 120623-OST, to include that a match is required for $1,500,000, and to remove District #5, clarifying that this is for Supervisor District #1

*I.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of the certification that the total revenues received by the Justice Courts and the Superior Court, including the Clerk of the Superior Court, exceed the amount received in the fiscal year 1997-98. The County Treasurer shall disburse the monies as directed pursuant to A.R.S. 41-2421, as amended. (Randee Stinson/Angeline Woods)

Item Action: Approved

*J.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of a Subrecipient Agreement between A New Leaf and Pinal County, through the Pinal County Board of Supervisors beginning January 1, 2025, ending December 31, 2026, for $200,000. A New Leaf will provide tenant based rental assistance to qualified populations within Pinal County in accordance with the Pinal County FFY2024-2028 Consolidated Plan and approved by the Board of Supervisors in the FFY24 Annual Action Plan. (Heather Patel/Angeline Woods)

Item Action: Approved

*K.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD22-114B rescinding  previously approved Resolution No. 042424-RD22-114A and Assignment and Assumption of SR 347 Rights of Way across the Ak-Chin Indian Community from Pinal County to the Arizona Department of Transportation located in Sections 03, 04, 33, 34, Township 04 South, Range 03 East. Supervisor District #1. (RD22-114B) (Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*L.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-083 accepting a Warranty Deed from Mountain View Community Church, an Arizona non-profit organization, for right of way to a portion on Papago Road. Supervisor District #1. (RD24-083) (Celeste Garza/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*M.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-092 accepting Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. 0256401, associated with Palomino Ranch-Parcel 6, located in Section 18, Township 5 South, Range 3 East. Supervisor District #1. (RD24-092) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*N.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-093 accepting Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. 0256400, associated with Palomino Ranch-Parcel 9, located in Section 18, Township 5 South, Range 3 East. Supervisor District #1. (RD24-093) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*O.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-085 accepting an Increase Penalty Rider to increase the amount of previously accepted Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. US00134825SU24A, associated with Ware Farms Parcel 2, located in Section 33, Township 2 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-085) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*P.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-086 accepting an Increase Penalty Rider to increase the amount of previously accepted Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. SU1197212, associated with Ware Farms Parcel 9, located in Section 33, Township 2 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-086) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*Q.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-087 accepting an Increase Penalty Rider to increase the amount of previously accepted Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. SU1197213, associated with Ware Farms Parcel 10, located in Section 33, Township 2 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-087) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*R.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-088 accepting an Increase Penalty Rider to increase the amount of previously accepted Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. SU1197214, associated with Ware Farms Parcel 11, located in Section 33, Township 2 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-088) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*S.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-089 accepting an Increase Penalty Rider to increase the amount of previously accepted Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. 7901181754, associated with Ware Farms Parcel 12, located in Section 33, Township 2 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-089) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*T.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-090 accepting an Increase Penalty Rider to increase the amount of previously accepted Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. 7901181755, associated with Ware Farms Parcel 13, located in Section 33, Township 2 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-090) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*U.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-094 releasing the current financial assurance Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. 72BSBIR9331, associated with Bella Vista Farms Parcels C&D-Parcel 3, and accepting Maintenance Bond No. 72BSBIR9331-M, located in Sections 15 & 16, Township 3 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-094) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*V.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-095 releasing the current financial assurance Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. 72BSBIR9332, associated with Bella Vista Farms Parcels C&D-Parcel 4, and accepting Maintenance Bond No. 72BSBIR9332-M, located in Section 15, Township 3 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-095) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*W.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-096 releasing the current financial assurance Subdivision Improvement Performance Bond No. 72BSBIR9329, associated with Bella Vista Farms Parcels C&D-Parcel 6, and accepting Maintenance Bond No. 72BSBIR9329-M, located in Sections 15 & 16, Township 3 South, Range 8 East. Supervisor District #2. (RD24-096) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*X.Discussion/approval/disapproval of a transfer of $110,000 in Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Entitlements from San Manuel Airport to Pinal Airpark. This will make use of funds that will be expiring in San Manuel to a ready project at Pinal Airpark. Supervisor District #4. (AD24-008) (James Petty/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*Y.Discussion/approval/disapproval of a Final Plat for Red Rock Village IXB. Supervisor District #4. (FP22-070) (Muhannad Zubi/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*Z.Discussion/approval/disapproval of a Final Plat for Red Rock Village IXC. Supervisor District #4. (FP22-071) (Muhannad Zubi/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*AA.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-084 releasing Maintenance Bond No. 024244093-M, associated with Entrada Del Oro Unit 2 Parcel 1B-1, located in Section 30, Township 1 South, Range 10 East. Supervisor District #5. (RD24-084) (Christopher Wanamaker/Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*AB.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 010825-RD24-091 authorizing the sale of County owned right of way known as Sleepy Hollow Trail. Section 9, Township 1 South, Range 9 East. Supervisor District #5. (RD24-091) (Joe Ortiz)

Item Action: Approved

*AC.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Special Event Permit SEP-024-24: Gold Canyon Arts Festival hosted by the Gold Canyon Arts Council; to be held at the Gold Canyon United Methodist Church on January 25, 2025. Permitted upon fulfillment of fire and medical staffing agreement, traffic plan, and emergency action plan. Supervisor District #5. (Valerie Lujan/Brent Billingsley)

Item Action: Approved

*AD.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of Special Event Permit SEP-025-24: Native American Arts Festival hosted by the Superstition Mountain Museum located at 4087 E. Apache Trail in Apache Junction, AZ; to be held on January 18 and 19, 2025. Permitted upon fulfillment of ADOT right-of-way use permit and emergency action plan. Supervisor District #5. (Valerie Lujan/Brent Billingsley)

Item Action: Approved

*AE.

Discussion/approval/disapproval of the following appointments for Precinct Committeemen for the Democratic Party:

Appointments:

Supervisor District 1:

Precinct #78 Patrick Melvin, 22364 N. Sunset Dr., Maricopa, 85139

Precinct #78 Rhonda Melvin, 22364 N. Sunset Dr., Maricopa, 85139

Supervisor District #3:

Precinct #22 Keith Seaman, 5009 N. Overfield Rd., Casa Grande, 85194

Supervisor District #5:

Precinct #40 Geoffry Fitzwater, 1414 E. 25th Ave, Apt # 2, Apache Junction, 85119 (Dana Lewis)

Item Action: Approved

*AF.Discussion/approval/disapproval of a Commercial Lease Agreement between Mary C. O'Brien Accommodation District and Pinal County. (Jill Broussard)

Item Action: Approved

*AG.Discussion/approval/disapproval of Subrecipient Agreement 23-AZDOHS-HSGP-230307-01 Amendment #1 under the Arizona Department of Homeland Security (AZDOHS) Grant Program and Pinal County, through the Pinal County Board of Supervisors, to extend the grant beginning October 1, 2023, ending February 28, 2025, for $75,000, and authorize the execution of a Memorandum of Understanding which authorizes AZDOHS and financial reporting requirements outlined in Subrecipient Agreement Amendment #1. The grant will be used for the Elections Security Exercise. (Kore Redden/Merissa Mendoza)

Item Action: Approved

Regular Item
(6)Meeting of the Pinal County Library District Board of Directors. (Shawn Flecken/Cathryn Whalen)
Item Action: Convened into the Pinal County Library District Board Agenda
(7)

Call to the Public— A "call to the public" is the time period for members of the public to address the Board of Supervisors to provide public input relating to subject matter within the Board of Supervisors authority or jurisdiction. Those wishing to address the Board of Supervisors need not request permission in advance. Action taken as a result of public comment will be limited to directing staff to study the matter or rescheduling it for further consideration and decision at a later date.

Click Here for Call to the Public Guidelines

Item Action: Public Comments
(8)Public Hearing and discussion/approval/disapproval of Resolution No. 2025-SUP-017-24, a Resolution approving case SUP-017-24, Graham Chapmam and Scott Hopper – Pinnacle Consulting LLC, applicant/agent, Dollar Self Storage #23 LLC, landowner, requesting approval of a Special Use Permit to operate a wireless communication facility, on a 6.45± acre parcel in the General Business (CB-2) Zone; tax parcel 200-25-002L  – legal on file –  situated in a portion of Section 10, Township 04 South, Range 08 East, of the Gila Salt River Baseline & Meridian, Pinal County, Arizona, located northeast of E. Hunt Hwy and approximately 620 feet south of E Heritage Rd in San Tan Valley, Pinal County. The Planning Commission recommended approval (9 to 0) of case SUP-017-24 with thirteen (13) stipulations. Supervisor District #4. (Patrick Zaia-Roberts/Brent Billingsley) 
Item Action: Approved as presented with 13 Stipulations
(9)Discussion/approval/disapproval of the appointment of Chairman of the Board of Supervisors effective Thursday, January 9, 2025, through Wednesday, December 31, 2025. (Mike Goodman)
Item Action: Approved Appointing Supervisor Stephen Q. Miller as Chairman
(10)Discussion/approval/disapproval of the appointment of Vice Chairman of the Board of Supervisors effective Thursday, January 9, 2025, through Wednesday, December 31, 2025. (Mike Goodman) 
Item Action: Approved Appointing Supervisor Jeffrey McClure as Vice-Chairman
(11)Executive Session pursuant to A.R.S. 38-431.03(A)(3)(4) for legal advice/litigation regarding Fontes v. Kevin Cavanaugh, et. al, Arizona Court of Appeals Case No. 2 CA-CV 2024-0310 (appeal of Pinal County Superior Court case No. CV2024-02541). (Chris Keller)
Item Action: Convened into Executive Session
(12)Executive Session pursuant to A.R.S. 38-431.03(A)(1) to discuss employment and salary consideration based on the experience, background, and qualifications of the specific candidates related to the following positions within the County Attorney's Office - County Attorney Manager (Position Number: 0117), County Attorney Chief of Staff (Position Number: 4294), Deputy Chief County Attorney (Chief Civil Deputy, Position Number: 0094) and County Attorney Chief Deputy (Position Number: 0076) (Brad Miller)
Item Action: Convened into Executive Session
(13)Discussion/approval/disapproval pursuant to county policy 4.20  to approve salaries above the midpoint, but within the applicable salary range, retroactive to the individual's start date, and authorize the County Manager to approve the same,  for the following positions specific to the County Attorney's Office based on the experience, background, and qualifications for the specific individuals discussed in executive session on January 8, 2025 - County Attorney Manager (Position Number: 0117), County Attorney Chief of Staff (Position Number: 4294), Deputy Chief County Attorney (Chief Civil Deputy, Position Number: 0094) and County Attorney Chief Deputy (Position Number: 0076). (Brad Miller)
Item Action: Approved salaries above the midpoint, but that it would be based between midpoint and third quartile, for the following positions; County Attorney Chief of Staff, Deputy Chief County Attorney (Chief Civil Deputy), and County Attorney Chief Deputy
(14)Discussion/approval/disapproval pursuant to Arizona Revised Statutes 11-419 of the annual salary for the appointment of Gina Godbehere as Pinal County Attorney Chief Deputy, Criminal Division, Position Number: 0076, Grade 26, in the amount of $_______ to be effective January 1, 2025. (Brad Miller)

Item Action: Approved to allow the County Manager to approve the salary above the midpoint, to be $190,000, for the Pinal County Attorney Chief Deputy, Criminal Division

Adjournment